Between rally there always fake bear on stochastic
it's a top-down idea, I just want to show my view on stochastic
there is always a fake bear between rally or between 2 bottom
fake bear = red circle
real bottom = blue circle
that's why it's really important to see 2200$ or more (if really hit there) as signal to new higher high later
there is always a fake bear between rally or between 2 bottom
fake bear = red circle
real bottom = blue circle
that's why it's really important to see 2200$ or more (if really hit there) as signal to new higher high later
Комментарий:
weekly example
Комментарий:
daily
Комментарий:
Комментарий:
Комментарий:
on 1H the suspicious 1825 bottom or fake bear cleared IMO, just need to wait for 1890
Комментарий:
in 15min really hard because a lot of divergence (it also happen in 1h)
Комментарий:
conclusion 1
+ good to understand stochastic, making fake bear and a new HH without bullish divergence
+ only work using stochastic, no other indicators can reach the bottom as fast as stochastic
+ almost good on every TF
- not reliable to determine top or bottom (or trend reversal signal)
but can be used when a fake bear or real bottom failed to make a new HH
- divergence ruined the signal (the rally start not on bottom of stochastic)
+ good to understand stochastic, making fake bear and a new HH without bullish divergence
+ only work using stochastic, no other indicators can reach the bottom as fast as stochastic
+ almost good on every TF
- not reliable to determine top or bottom (or trend reversal signal)
but can be used when a fake bear or real bottom failed to make a new HH
- divergence ruined the signal (the rally start not on bottom of stochastic)
Комментарий:
loks like 15TF not good for deep retrace down , so I wonder maybe it will show a downtrend
Комментарий:
monitoring 30min for now
Комментарий:
work on 5 min too
Комментарий:
4H update, add RSI to backtest it to see is there any correlation or not
Комментарий:
I wonder will see retrace down under 1860 or not
the chart say so but it could be ruined by 1920-1930 spike IMO
the chart say so but it could be ruined by 1920-1930 spike IMO
Комментарий:
5min looks bearish
but monday always ignore TA, I dont think it wise... especially rely on 5min TF
but monday always ignore TA, I dont think it wise... especially rely on 5min TF
Комментарий:
15m really hard to predict
Комментарий:
m30 clear down trend but...
it's too premature to seek blue bottom while it possible red fake bear to achieve 1930 bullish target
it's too premature to seek blue bottom while it possible red fake bear to achieve 1930 bullish target
Комментарий:
I think I find a way to determine which is red which is blue
Комментарий:
I just noticed 2 failed fake bears, this things not good...
1. fake bear usually always make a new HH
2. divergence and failed fake bear usually downtrend but it's wrong
3. could lead to a buyer trap (I want to argue just use SL+) but that just downgrade the signal as 50:50(up or down) which not good
1. fake bear usually always make a new HH
2. divergence and failed fake bear usually downtrend but it's wrong
3. could lead to a buyer trap (I want to argue just use SL+) but that just downgrade the signal as 50:50(up or down) which not good
Комментарий:
looks like SL+ is a must
backtest just showed more trap and sl hunt and not showed fake bear on 1H
backtest just showed more trap and sl hunt and not showed fake bear on 1H
Комментарий:
I will blacklist 1H TF for a while... and use 30min instead
but there is 1 thing must be accepted on 30min, the downtrend is there
but there is 1 thing must be accepted on 30min, the downtrend is there
Комментарий:
man just switch to 30min and find another problem should I try to double check with 15min TF?
Комментарий:
headache 15min, but at least it clear signal
Комментарий:
interesting I make a mistake on the last 15m chart
Комментарий:
rare pattern, it's new on this backtest... if true then still not bearish trend on 15m TF
Комментарий:
very fun watching 15min TF
new pattern again... showing both bull and bear signal, Im waiting!!!
new pattern again... showing both bull and bear signal, Im waiting!!!
Комментарий:
forget this analysis work on a bullish trend not a downtrend, now it is useless to mark blue and red for now
Комментарий:
yeah switching to 5min still down trend IMO so messed up in down trend
Комментарий:
why not reverse the dot to the top, not the bottom? not that easy I tried but not reliable
kind like big TF still bullish so small TF favor bullish signal not bearish signal
kind like big TF still bullish so small TF favor bullish signal not bearish signal
Комментарий:
5 min really weird, no double 2 blue dot as reversal signal (divergence)
no clear red dot or fake bear on last spike maybe must stay away from 5 min TF
no clear red dot or fake bear on last spike maybe must stay away from 5 min TF
Комментарий:
15min also no clear reversal signal
either I'm wrong with the dot or downtrend not valid to use the dot
I need strategy to see reversal signal, so that home work for now
either I'm wrong with the dot or downtrend not valid to use the dot
I need strategy to see reversal signal, so that home work for now
Комментарий:
4H too premature to mark it as blue dot IMO
Комментарий:
IMO 4H still bearish but I will take note for now since RSI and stochastic lagged indicator (can change with spike) so the blue dot can become red dot (the pattern on RSI and stoch change due spike)
Комментарий:
surprisingly I see a new way to see a target, will backtest it later
Комментарий:
cannot use 5min TF as backtest not reliable